Returning to the debate over digital, CloserStill Media and Nineteen Group chairman Phil Soar asks what happens when you start with false assumptions.
I wrote last week about what had happened to “pivot to digital.” Let’s call it P2D for these purposes.
It provoked an unusual number of comments, many from those who still believe that our industry will ultimately be disrupted by digital/the web/social media et al.
Which got me to considering about why these views are clearly so strongly held. The most important reason, it seems to me, is about the internet landscape that completely surrounds the authors. And, alongside that, a belief about what trade shows really are and are not.
In a nutshell, the arrival of the web, then the broadband revolution in the 2001-2006 era, and then topped by the iPhone in 2007, has wreaked havoc across what we usually define as media. Newspapers and magazines are obvious. Traditional television has been upended by Netflix and Prime Video. Radio is losing ground to podcasts. Cinema continues to lose audiences as viewers can get first run movies as part of their Netflix subscription (and the largest cinema chain has gone into administration).
The core of the argument for believers in P2D is simple. Why should trade shows be the one medium which somehow dodges this revolution? At some point, trade shows must fall. I remember debating this with Duncan Painter at a conference a few years ago. He held the view strongly and acted on it – selling his Ascential assets for a very good price.
Is P2D the result of an erroneous syllogism?
My response is that this is a “logical” position which contains a false assumption, viz:
• Trade shows are a medium.
• All medium(s) have been, or will be, disrupted by P2D
• Hence trade shows will be disrupted by P2D
This is a syllogism as first defined by Aristotle, but I would argue that it is a false syllogism. (You can find plenty of these in the Daily Mail – try “some cats are black, and some black things are lumps of coal, thus some cats are lumps of coal” – this one is not actually from the Mail but the same error of logic is not uncommon. Or one which does appear regularly in the papers: “Men are either married or unmarried. Married men live longer than unmarried men. Thus marriage makes you healthy.” An excellent example of the false syllogism).
We can find false assumptions leading to consequent actions and undesirable conclusions everywhere. On the largest stage, the assumption that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. In our own world, that furniture buyers wanted more design and a cosmopolitan London base. That there were 7,500 people who wanted a two-bedroomed flat in Earl’s Court. Or that Brexit would lead to saving £350 million a week for the NHS.
My argument is a simple one. That calling trade shows a medium is a false assumption. Trade shows are something else and that is why (after two decades of waiting) we have yet to see Trade Shows significantly disrupted in the way many expected.
I have written about this before, so I will try to be brief. There are four basic reasons why trade shows are not a “typical” medium, nor indeed a classic medium at all.
- Firstly – the buyer comes to us, not the reverse
It is a truism that media goes to the buyer, not the other way round. Newpapers and magazines are delivered to the door (or the kiosk the buyer passes each morning). Television and radio are beamed into the home or the car. AdWords and advertisements on Facebook, Google or elsewhere are delivered straight to our hands. Car drivers can’t help driving past display advertising. But the buyer, the visitor, has to make the effort to go to trade shows – the trade show does not come to her. This must create a very different level of both interest and commitment. - Secondly – we do not price on cost per thousand
Media is always priced on cost per thousand – viewers, listeners, clicks, eyeballs or ears. It is always a function of how many people of a certain demographic (the demographic for Vogue is very different from the demographic for a holiday influencer on Instagram, but the principle is the same). But trade shows seem to ignore the number of “users”. Spring Fair will charge largely the same per square metre as Top Drawer, even though their audiences are massively different. Our biggest IT events charge roughly the same as events with one tenth of the number of attendees – and with very little serious attempt to “prove” that the smaller audience is somehow of a higher quality. Even display advertisers charge on how many cars, and of what social category, pass their advertisements each day. - Thirdly – we are transparent
Advertisers generally rely on the good faith of the media owners. They cannot possibly know how many readers a magazine really has, nor how many viewers were paying attention to their 15 second TV ad, nor what audience a pop-up really had. This is not to say that print, television and radio do not go to great lengths to try and provide decent audience analysis, but it is ultimately a matter of faith. How many readers really looked at that left hand page ad on page 34? How many viewers were paying attention in that commercial break?
But anyone can go to an exhibition. They can see the people in the hall. They can count them if they wish. They can tell whether there is a buzz or not. They can talk to as many exhibitors and visitors as they like – and ask them how satisfied they are with the event, whether it is meeting their expectations, whether it provides good value for money. We are completely transparent. - Fourthly – barriers to entry are very high
Very often the cost of launching a trade show in a secondary or tertiary venue is low. But the barriers to entry in a well populated sector at the major venue can be very high. This is because almost all major markets (the UK, France, Italy, Spain) have only two venues large enough for major events and even elsewhere (Germany, the USA) the nature of these markets makes it very difficult to create a leading event. In other words, the nature of the slot system. And this has been greatly compounded in the last 15 years by the adoption of the subscription system which we call re-booking on site. This has the effect (for many large events) that up to 100% of their exhibitors have already committed themselves to an existing, familiar, event one year out and are thus much less likely to support a start-up.
This is not true of classic media forms. There is nothing to stop you launching a newspaper or a magazine – WHS or Relay/NMPP will carry it. You can launch a TV Channel (there are thousands on our net in Florida) and you will easily find satellite and cable operators to carry it. And there are literally no barriers to entry for anyone wanting to launch almost anything on the web/internet. The problem for many, if not all, of these is the cost of finding and buying an audience. For trade shows, the cost of entry is not very high – but the barriers to success are very tall indeed.
And the world may be changing in our favour
There are straws in the wind, if you will. The steady decline of users of Facebook and other social media sites in the USA and Europe. That ecommerce did not take over the retail world post-pandemic. And more tightly defined symbols: BuzzFeed, the leader in internet sites which sought to become the main source of news for countless millions, closed its news division this month. The FT declared that it was “a sign of the waning fortunes of venture capital backed digital start-ups that had ambitions to disrupt.”
More precisely, Ben Smith, who was the founding editor of the Buzzfeed site, said: “People got sick of this sort of (digital) distribution and of social media in general. What they want now is something more human, more curated and built to help you navigate the chaos of fraying social media.” I may be chasing rainbows, but that sounds a bit like events to me
My purpose for yet again reiterating the reasons trade shows are different is to reinforce why, in my opinion, the basic case for P2D does not apply. Trade shows are not a medium, hence they will not be affected by the web etc in the way that media forms have been. Starting from the assumption that trade shows are a media form, and will thus be affected like other media, is (in my view) essentially false.
Postscript
Many of you will have noticed that the Competitions Commission recently stymied Microsoft’s bid for Activision, the video games company responsible for Call of Duty and Candy Crush, among others. The bid was for $75 billion. Among other thoughts, this did show that, when we look outside our own world, there are media segments of astonishing value.
But if Microsoft decided that it liked trade shows, it could buy up literally every available exhibition business in the world (starting in West London, but excluding the unbuyable Messen) and still have $50 billion of that $75 billion to spare.



